Cheap Flights from New York to Indiana from $76 Return

Flight deals from New York to Indiana

Looking for cheap tickets from New York to Indiana, or a last-minute trip? Find the lowest prices on one-way and return tickets right here.

Indianapolis.$76 per passenger.Departing Wed, 12 Mar, returning Tue, 18 Mar.Return flight with Spirit Airlines.Outbound direct flight with Spirit Airlines departs from New York Newark on Wed, 12 Mar, arriving in Indianapolis.Inbound direct flight with Spirit Airlines departs from Indianapolis on Tue, 18 Mar, arriving in New York Newark.Price includes taxes and charges.From $76, select.

Fort Wayne.$315 per passenger.Departing Tue, 25 Mar, returning Tue, 25 Mar.Return flight with Delta.Outbound indirect flight with Delta, departs from New York Newark on Tue, 25 Mar, arriving in Fort Wayne.Inbound indirect flight with Delta, departs from Fort Wayne on Tue, 25 Mar, arriving in New York Newark.Price includes taxes and charges.From $315, select.

South Bend.$315 per passenger.Departing Wed, 26 Mar, returning Tue, 1 Apr.Return flight with Delta.Outbound indirect flight with Delta, departs from New York Newark on Wed, 26 Mar, arriving in South Bend.Inbound indirect flight with Delta, departs from South Bend on Tue, 1 Apr, arriving in New York Newark.Price includes taxes and charges.From $315, select.

Evansville.$601 per passenger.Departing Sat, 19 Apr, returning Sat, 26 Apr.Return flight with Delta.Outbound indirect flight with Delta, departs from New York Newark on Sat, 19 Apr, arriving in Evansville.Inbound indirect flight with Delta, departs from Evansville on Sat, 26 Apr, arriving in New York John F. Kennedy.Price includes taxes and charges.From $601, select.

Flying from New York to Indiana

Arm yourself with these facts on the fly.

Cheapest flight found	$76, Indianapolis
Cheapest month to fly	March
Average flight time	2 hrs, 24 mins
Cheapest airport to fly from	New York Newark
Most popular airline	WestJet

How to find cheap flights from New York to Indiana

We've compared the best online travel agents and flight providers on the internet to find the cheapest plane tickets from New York to Indiana. Other savvy travellers recently found return flights from $76 and one-way tickets from $38 one-way. Ready to join them? Here are a few tips to help you do it the smart way.

Fly from New York Newark into Indianapolis

At the moment, the lowest priced flight tickets to Indiana are from New York Newark Airport to Indianapolis Airport.

Fly in March

We crunched the flight calendar and found the cheapest time to fly from New York to Indiana is currently March.

Fly on a Tuesday

From our data, we can see that Tuesday seems to be the cheapest time to fly from New York to Indiana.

Flex your dates for the best rates

If you’re flexible on your departure dates, you can use Skyscanner's whole month tool to find the cheapest day of the year to fly from New York to anywhere you choose in Indiana.

Watch as fares rise and fall

With Price Alerts, we'll let you know when flight prices from New York to Indiana go up or down so you can book when the time is just right.

Relax – these are fee-free flight tickets

With us, there are no added fees – the New York to Indiana flight price you see when you search with us is what you pay to the provider.

Frequently asked questions

What's the average New York to Indiana flight price?

We looked at all of the upcoming return flights from New York to Indiana we could find over the next 12 months. It looks like $76 is the best price. This is good, compared to the average Indiana ticket price of $419.

What is the cheapest month to fly from New York to Indiana?

The cheapest month to fly from New York to Evansville Airport is usually April. The cheapest month to fly from New York to South Bend Airport is usually March. The cheapest month to fly from New York to Indianapolis Airport is usually March. And the cheapest month to fly from New York to Fort Wayne Airport is usually March.

Which upcoming date is cheapest to fly from New York to Indiana on?

After crunching the numbers on our flight calendar, we found that it is currently cheapest to fly from New York to Indiana on Wednesday, 12 March 2025.

Are there any direct flights from New York to Indiana?

New York Newark Airport offers direct flights to Indiana.

If I'm flying from New York, where in Indiana is cheapest to fly into?

If you're flying from New York, the cheapest city in Indiana to fly into is Indianapolis. The cheapest airport serving Indianapolis at the moment is Indianapolis.